Skip to content
Mon to Sat, 10 to 6, by appointment MCMiami Coin BuyersCoins · Gold · Silver (786) 783-0890

Home › What we buy › Old coins and proof sets

Selling old U.S. coins in Miami

Albums, blue folders, rolls, proof sets and jars of change. We separate the silver, grade the coins that deserve it and tell you plainly which ones are common.

Coin album with a magnifier

Collections that came south

Many South Florida coin collections were built up north. A father in Brooklyn filled folders from his change. A mother in Ohio ordered a proof set every year from the Mint. When they retired to Aventura, Kendall or Hollywood, the coins came along.

Their children are often the ones calling us now, sometimes from out of state, sometimes while clearing out a condo with a closing date coming up.

Dates that get a second look

None of these is a sure thing, but each gets checked closely.

  • Wheat cents from 1909-S VDB, 1914-D and 1931-S
  • Buffalo nickels with full dates, and the 1937-D three-legged
  • Mercury dimes from 1916-D and 1921
  • Standing Liberty quarters with full dates
  • Franklin halves with full bell lines
  • Carson City silver dollars

Mint marks

A mint mark is a small letter showing where a coin was made: D for Denver, S for San Francisco, O for New Orleans and CC for Carson City. Most Philadelphia coins carry none. The same year can be common from Philadelphia and scarce from San Francisco. You do not have to sort anything ahead of time, because we look at every coin anyway.

Humidity and old coins

South Florida air is hard on coins. Copper darkens or turns green, and cardboard folders grow spots. Skip the silver polish and the baking soda. Move coins to an air-conditioned room, leave them in their holders and bring them as they are.

Errors and oddities

Doubled dies, off-center strikes and missing clad layers interest collectors. Most suspected errors are damage that happened after the coin left the mint. A loupe usually settles which kind you have in a few seconds, and we show you what we see.

Pocket change from the old neighborhood

We often see coffee cans of wheat cents and buffalo nickels gathered in Brooklyn, the Bronx or Philadelphia in the 1950s and 1960s, carried south decades later. Most wheat cents are worth a few cents each, buffalo nickels without dates a little less. We still look at every one, because the 1909-S VDB and 1914-D cents have both turned up in cans like these.

Foreign coins in the same box

U.S. collections here usually come mixed with Canadian change, souvenir coins from cruises and Latin American coins brought from home. We sort it all on the table. Silver goes by weight, collector coins by grade and the rest goes back in the box with a note on what it is.

Coins we buy

  • Indian Head and wheat cents
  • Buffalo nickels and silver war nickels
  • Silver dimes, quarters and halves through 1964
  • Kennedy halves from 1965 to 1970
  • Morgan and Peace silver dollars
  • Proof sets and mint sets
  • Graded coins in sealed holders

How old coins are priced

U.S. silver coins dated 1964 or earlier always carry at least their silver value. Copper and nickel coins start at face. Date, mint and condition decide how far above that floor a coin goes.

Better coins go on the offer one by one with date, grade and price. The rest are grouped by type.

Further reading: Proof set and mint set values

Questions families ask

Are proof sets worth anything?

Any set holding silver coins is worth no less than its silver. Most clad sets sell near face. Our guide explains which years carry premiums.

Do you buy coin albums?

Yes. Leave the coins in the album and we will look at each one there.

Should I clean my coins?

No. Cleaning lowers the value.

Request a free appraisal

We call back the same day. Se habla español.

Families also ask us about

Silver coins and sterlingFree appraisals